How Not to Plant a Tree: A Guide to Botanical Blunders

Planting a tree seems simple enough, right? Dig a hole, pop in the sapling, and watch it grow. However, the path to a thriving tree is paved with potential pitfalls. Improper planting is a major cause of tree death, often stemming from well-intentioned but ultimately detrimental actions. This guide delves into the common mistakes people make when planting trees, ensuring your green investment flourishes for generations.

Choosing the Wrong Tree for the Wrong Place

One of the most significant errors occurs before you even break ground: selecting an unsuitable tree species for your environment. Ignoring factors like climate, soil type, and available space is a recipe for disaster.

Ignoring Climate and Hardiness Zones

Trees have specific climate requirements. Planting a tree that can’t tolerate your region’s temperature extremes is a guaranteed failure. The USDA Plant Hardiness Zone Map provides crucial information, indicating the average minimum winter temperatures in different regions. Choosing a tree suited to your zone ensures it can survive the coldest months. Planting a Zone 7 tree in Zone 5, for example, exposes it to temperatures it simply isn’t built to withstand. Always check the USDA Plant Hardiness Zone Map before selecting your tree.

Neglecting Soil Type and Drainage

Soil is the foundation of a tree’s life. Different trees thrive in different soil types – some prefer well-drained sandy soil, while others tolerate clay. Soil pH (acidity or alkalinity) is also a critical factor. Conduct a soil test to determine your soil’s composition and pH level. This simple step will reveal whether your soil is suitable for your chosen tree, or if amendments are necessary. Poor drainage is a common problem, leading to root rot. Ensure the planting site doesn’t become waterlogged after rain.

Overlooking Available Space

Trees grow, often much larger than people anticipate. Planting a large tree species too close to buildings, power lines, or other structures will inevitably lead to problems. Roots can damage foundations and underground utilities, while branches can interfere with overhead lines and obstruct views. Consider the mature size of the tree when selecting a planting location. Give it ample space to spread its branches and roots without causing harm to its surroundings.

The Perils of Improper Planting Techniques

Even with the right tree in the right location, improper planting techniques can doom it. Focus on proper hole preparation, root management, and initial care.

Digging the Wrong Size Hole

The adage “bigger is better” doesn’t always apply, but it’s often true for planting holes. A hole that’s too small restricts root growth, while a hole that’s too deep can lead to root suffocation. The ideal hole should be at least twice as wide as the root ball, but only as deep as the distance from the top of the root ball to the point where the trunk flares out. The trunk flare, where the trunk widens at the base, should always be visible above the soil line. This prevents the trunk from being buried, which can cause rot.

Mishandling the Roots

The roots are the lifeline of a tree. Damaging them during planting significantly reduces its chances of survival.

Root Bound Trees

Many container-grown trees have root systems that are tightly circling the inside of the pot – a condition known as “root bound.” If left uncorrected, these circling roots will continue to grow in a circular pattern, eventually girdling the tree and restricting nutrient uptake. Before planting, gently loosen the root ball and prune any circling or girdling roots. Tease the roots apart to encourage them to grow outwards into the surrounding soil. For severely root-bound trees, consider making several vertical cuts along the root ball to sever the circling roots.

Bare Root Trees

Bare root trees, trees sold without soil around their roots, require special handling. Keep the roots moist at all times before planting. Soak them in water for a few hours before planting to rehydrate them. Spread the roots out evenly in the planting hole, ensuring they are not tangled or cramped.

Damaging the Root Ball

Handle the root ball of balled-and-burlapped trees with care. Avoid dropping or dragging it, as this can damage the delicate roots. When placing the tree in the hole, carefully remove any twine or burlap that is constricting the trunk. However, leave the burlap around the root ball intact; it will eventually decompose.

Planting Too Deep or Too Shallow

Planting too deep is a common and often fatal mistake. Burying the trunk flare deprives the roots of oxygen and promotes rot. Conversely, planting too shallow exposes the roots to air and can lead to dehydration. The ideal depth is to have the trunk flare slightly above the surrounding soil level. After planting, the top of the root ball should be even with or slightly above the existing grade.

Compacting the Soil

Soil compaction restricts root growth and reduces water infiltration. Avoid compacting the soil around the tree when backfilling the planting hole. Gently tamp the soil to remove air pockets, but don’t pack it down too tightly. Add organic matter, such as compost, to improve soil structure and drainage.

Neglecting Post-Planting Care

Planting is just the first step. Neglecting ongoing care can undo all your hard work.

Improper Watering

Watering is crucial, especially during the first few years after planting. However, overwatering is just as harmful as underwatering. Water deeply and less frequently, allowing the soil to dry out slightly between waterings. The frequency of watering will depend on the weather and soil conditions. Use a soaker hose or drip irrigation to deliver water directly to the root zone.

Insufficient Mulching

Mulch is a tree’s best friend. It helps retain moisture, suppress weeds, and regulate soil temperature. Apply a layer of organic mulch, such as wood chips or shredded bark, around the base of the tree, keeping it a few inches away from the trunk to prevent rot. A mulch layer of 2-4 inches is ideal. Avoid piling mulch against the trunk, creating a “mulch volcano,” which can trap moisture and encourage pests and diseases.

Ignoring Staking and Pruning

Staking provides support for newly planted trees, especially in windy areas. However, staking should be temporary. Remove the stakes after one year to allow the tree to develop a strong root system. Pruning can help shape the tree and remove any dead or damaged branches. However, avoid excessive pruning, as this can weaken the tree. Focus on removing crossing or rubbing branches to improve air circulation.

Failing to Protect from Pests and Diseases

Newly planted trees are vulnerable to pests and diseases. Monitor your tree regularly for signs of infestation or disease. Early detection is key to successful treatment. Consult with a local arborist or extension agent for advice on pest and disease control. Consider using tree guards to protect the trunk from rodents and other animals.

Forgetting Fertilization

While not always necessary, fertilization can give newly planted trees a boost. However, avoid fertilizing at the time of planting. Wait until the tree has established itself before applying fertilizer. Use a slow-release fertilizer formulated for trees. Follow the instructions on the fertilizer label carefully.

Common Tree Planting Mistakes to Avoid

To summarize, here is a quick reference of mistakes to avoid:

  • Ignoring the USDA Plant Hardiness Zone.
  • Failing to assess soil type and drainage.
  • Underestimating the mature size of the tree.
  • Digging a hole that is too small or too deep.
  • Neglecting to address root-bound conditions.
  • Planting the tree too deep or too shallow.
  • Compacting the soil around the root ball.
  • Overwatering or underwatering.
  • Creating a “mulch volcano”.
  • Leaving stakes on for too long.
  • Ignoring signs of pests or diseases.
  • Improperly pruning the tree.
  • Forgetting to fertilize, if needed, after establishment.

By avoiding these common mistakes, you can ensure your newly planted tree thrives and provides beauty and benefits for years to come. Remember to research your chosen tree species, prepare the planting site carefully, and provide ongoing care.

What is the most common mistake people make when planting a tree?

The most frequent error is planting the tree too deeply. When the root flare, the point where the trunk widens to join the roots, is buried underground, the tree’s bark becomes susceptible to rot and girdling roots can develop. This inhibits the transport of water and nutrients, effectively suffocating the tree over time.
Ensuring that the root flare is partially visible after planting is crucial. Dig the hole wide and shallow, allowing the top of the root ball or bare roots to sit slightly above the surrounding ground level. Backfill with soil, gently sloping away from the trunk to promote drainage and prevent water from pooling.

How important is the size of the planting hole?

The size of the planting hole is extremely important for the successful establishment of a new tree. A hole that is too small restricts root growth, forcing the roots to circle within the confines of the hole and potentially leading to root girdling. This can weaken the tree and make it vulnerable to pests, diseases, and drought.
Conversely, a hole that is too deep can cause the tree to settle too low, burying the root flare. The ideal hole should be at least twice as wide as the root ball, but no deeper than the root ball’s height. This provides ample space for the roots to expand outwards and establish a strong foundation.

What is root girdling, and how can it be prevented?

Root girdling occurs when roots circle around the trunk of the tree, constricting the flow of water and nutrients. This essentially strangles the tree, causing it to weaken, become susceptible to disease, and eventually die. It’s often caused by planting too deeply or by allowing roots to circle within a container for too long before planting.
Prevention starts with careful root inspection before planting. Gently tease apart any circling roots, especially those that are thick and woody. If the roots are severely matted or circling, carefully prune them back to encourage new, outward growth. Proper planting depth and a wide planting hole also contribute to preventing root girdling.

What kind of soil should I use when planting a tree?

While it might seem intuitive to amend the soil with fertilizers or compost, using highly amended soil in the planting hole can actually hinder root development. The roots may become accustomed to the enriched environment and reluctant to venture out into the surrounding native soil, potentially creating a “pot-bound” effect.
It’s generally best to use the existing native soil when backfilling the planting hole. If the soil is extremely poor, you can lightly amend it with a small amount of compost, but be sure to mix it thoroughly with the native soil. This allows the roots to gradually adapt to the surrounding soil conditions and encourages them to grow outwards in search of nutrients and water.

How much should I water a newly planted tree?

Proper watering is essential for the survival of a newly planted tree, but overwatering can be just as detrimental as underwatering. Overwatering can lead to root rot, a condition where the roots are suffocated by excessive moisture and become susceptible to fungal infections. This can weaken the tree and eventually kill it.
Water deeply and infrequently, allowing the soil to dry slightly between waterings. The frequency will depend on the climate, soil type, and the tree species. Check the soil moisture by digging a few inches down near the root ball. If the soil feels dry to the touch, it’s time to water. Avoid frequent, shallow waterings, which encourage shallow root growth.

Should I stake my newly planted tree?

Staking is often used to provide support to newly planted trees, but it’s not always necessary and can even be detrimental if done improperly. Staking can restrict the tree’s natural movement, preventing it from developing a strong, tapered trunk and robust root system. The tree may become reliant on the stakes for support and weaken over time.
Only stake a tree if it’s planted in a windy location or if it’s top-heavy and at risk of falling over. Use flexible ties that allow for some movement, and remove the stakes after one growing season. This will encourage the tree to develop its own strength and stability. Avoid using wire or other materials that can girdle the trunk.

What is the best time of year to plant a tree?

The ideal time to plant a tree depends on the climate and the type of tree. Generally, the best times are during the dormant seasons, either in the fall or early spring. Planting during these times allows the tree to establish its root system before the stresses of hot summer weather or cold winter conditions.
Fall planting is particularly beneficial in regions with mild winters, as the soil is still warm enough to encourage root growth. Spring planting allows the tree to establish roots before the heat of summer arrives. Avoid planting during the heat of summer or when the ground is frozen, as these conditions can make it difficult for the tree to survive.

Leave a Comment